The History of the Winchester Model 1873: The Gun That Won the West

03/2025
Author: Dave
Mar 05, 2025
???? 5 mins
A picture of Winchester Model 1873 with USA Gun Store

The Winchester Model 1873 is one of the most legendary rifles in American history. Dubbed “The Gun That Won the West” this iconic lever-action rifle played a crucial role in shaping the American frontier. With its rugged design, reliability, and widespread adoption, the Model 1873 became a favorite among settlers, cowboys, lawmen, and outlaws alike. This article explores the history, design, accessories, optics, users, pros and cons, and modern alternatives to the Winchester 1873.

The Origins of the Winchester Model 1873

The Winchester Repeating Arms Company introduced the Model 1873 as an improvement on previous lever-action designs. It was based on the earlier Model 1866 but featured a stronger steel receiver, making it more durable and capable of handling the more powerful .44-40 Winchester centerfire cartridge. This innovation allowed shooters to use the same ammunition in both their rifles and revolvers, a major advantage for those on the frontier.

The rifle quickly gained popularity, with more than 720,000 units produced between 1873 and 1919. It was available in multiple barrel lengths and calibers, including .38-40 and .32-20, making it a versatile choice for hunting, self-defense, and law enforcement. The Model 1873 represented a significant step forward in firearms technology, offering users a more efficient, powerful, and practical rifle compared to many of its predecessors.

Key Features and Design

The Winchester Model 1873 was designed with durability, functionality, and ease of use in mind. It incorporated several features that made it stand out from other rifles of its era:

  • Caliber Options: Originally chambered in .44-40 Winchester, later models also included .38-40 and .32-20, providing shooters with options suited for various uses.
  • Lever-Action Mechanism: Allowed for rapid firing, giving shooters a distinct advantage in combat, hunting, and self-defense scenarios.
  • Steel Receiver: Unlike its predecessor, the brass-framed Model 1866, the Model 1873 featured a steel receiver for enhanced durability and reliability.
  • Tubular Magazine: Held between 10-15 rounds, depending on the barrel length, offering users a substantial amount of firepower without constant reloading.
  • Barrel Lengths: Available in carbine (20 inches), rifle (24 inches), and musket (30 inches) configurations, catering to different user preferences and needs.

These features made the Model 1873 a well-rounded rifle that could be used effectively in various environments, from rugged landscapes to urban settings where law enforcement needed reliable firepower.

Who Used the Winchester Model 1873?

A picture of Winchester Model 1873 1 with USA Gun Store

The Winchester 1873 was widely adopted by various groups, including:

  • Cowboys & Ranchers: Valued for its reliability and ease of use in open-range environments, making it a trusted tool for protecting livestock and property.
  • Lawmen & Outlaws: Used by legendary figures like Wyatt Earp, Billy the Kid, and Pat Garrett, the rifle played a role in both enforcing and breaking the law.
  • Hunters & Settlers: Ideal for hunting deer and other mid-sized game, providing settlers with a dependable firearm for both sustenance and protection.
  • Military & Militias: Some militia groups and law enforcement agencies adopted the rifle for its rapid-fire capability and durability in rugged conditions.

Favorite Accessories & Optics

While the Model 1873 was primarily an iron-sight rifle, some shooters customized their weapons with accessories, including:

  • Tang Sights: Improved long-range accuracy by providing better sight alignment.
  • Lyman or Marbles Peep Sights: Offered enhanced sighting precision, especially for distance shooting.
  • Engraved & Custom Stocks: Many owners personalized their rifles with intricate engravings and custom wood stocks, making their rifles unique.
  • Saddle Ring Attachments: Allowed for easy carrying on horseback, an essential feature for cowboys and mounted lawmen.

These accessories allowed users to enhance the performance and aesthetic appeal of their Model 1873, making it not only a functional firearm but also a statement piece.

Pros & Cons of the Winchester Model 1873

A picture of Pros and Cons with USA Gun Store

Pros:

  • Fast Lever-Action: The rapid-fire capability was unmatched for its time, giving shooters a clear advantage. 
  • Ammunition Compatibility: Being able to use the same ammo for both rifle and revolver was a major advantage, reducing the need for carrying multiple types of ammunition. 
  • Durability & Reliability: Built to withstand harsh frontier conditions, making it a favorite among those who depended on their rifle daily. 
  • Ergonomic Design: Comfortable to shoulder and shoot, even for extended periods, thanks to its well-balanced design. 
  • High Magazine Capacity: With up to 15 rounds in the tubular magazine, it provided more firepower than many other rifles of its time.

Cons:

  • Limited Long-Range Accuracy: Effective range was around 200 yards, making it less suitable for long-distance engagements compared to bolt-action rifles. 
  • Tubular Magazine Limitations: Reloading was slower compared to modern magazine-fed rifles, requiring rounds to be loaded one at a time. 
  • Weight: Heavier than some competing rifles, which could be a drawback for those needing to carry it over long distances.

Modern Alternatives to the Winchester 1873

While the Model 1873 remains a beloved classic, modern lever-action rifles offer similar benefits with improved materials and technology:

  • Winchester Model 1892: A refined, lighter version of the 1873 with better handling and enhanced firepower.
  • Marlin 1894: Popular for its smooth action and modern build quality, making it a favorite among lever-action enthusiasts.
  • Henry Big Boy: A modern take on the lever-action rifle, available in a variety of calibers and featuring a classic aesthetic.
  • Uberti Reproduction 1873: High-quality replicas for those who want an authentic experience with modern craftsmanship and reliability.

These alternatives offer shooters the timeless appeal of lever-action rifles while incorporating modern innovations that improve functionality and ease of use.

Conclusion

The Winchester Model 1873 earned its title as “The Gun That Won the West” due to its reliability, rapid-fire capabilities, and widespread use. Whether in the hands of lawmen, outlaws, cowboys, or settlers, this rifle played an undeniable role in American history. Its impact on the development of the American frontier cannot be overstated, as it provided a dependable means of protection, hunting, and law enforcement.

Today, the Model 1873 remains a highly sought-after collector’s item and a favorite among Western shooting enthusiasts. Its enduring legacy continues to capture the imagination of firearm enthusiasts, historians, and those who appreciate the craftsmanship and ingenuity of classic firearms. Whether displayed as a historical artifact or used in cowboy action shooting competitions, the Winchester Model 1873 stands as a testament to a bygone era of American history.

Share with:
Dave
Related posts
More about USA Gun Store
<?php

// Get the current post's categories
$post_categories = get_the_category();

// Find the parent category of the current post's categories
$parent_category = null;
foreach ($post_categories as $category) {
    if ($category->parent == 0) {
        $parent_category = $category;
        break;
    }
}

// Get the children categories of the parent category
if ($parent_category) {
    $args = array(
        'parent' => $parent_category->term_id, // Get children categories of the parent category
        'hide_empty' => 0,                     // Get categories even if they have no posts
    );

    $children_categories = get_categories($args);

    // Prepare an array to hold the children category IDs
    $children_category_ids = array();

    // Loop through each child category and add its ID to the children array
    foreach ($children_categories as $child_category) {
        $children_category_ids[] = $child_category->term_id;
    }

    add_filter('bricks/terms/query_vars', function ($query_vars, $settings, $element_id) use ($children_category_ids) {
        // Get only the children categories of the current post's parent category
        if ($element_id == 'jnniub') {
            $query_vars['include'] = $children_category_ids;
        }
    
        return $query_vars;
    }, 10, 3);
}

?>
Welcome to USA Gun Store, in order to browse our site you must be at least 18 years of age.
Are you at least 18 years old?
No
Your Cart

Subtotal: $319.90

Total: $319.90

View CartCheckout